mtg the game card Ranking Every "You Win" Magic In Commander: #25-16 The Magic of Gatherings: A

He worked a lot differently back in the day before the rules changes, but he is still just as strong (some might even argue stronger!)

It's still a lot of extra power just for hitting land drops, which is a big deal in decks designed to get a bunch of extra lands into play

Ultimately this blue card depends on how easy you can get it out on turn 3 or before, but the potential is there

Wizards has shown reluctance to reprint very expensive cards close to their original rarity especially if they can be detrimental to a draft format

It's very powerful in Commander since so many things care about ETB stuff from the heavily played Mulldrifter and Eternal Witness with their ETB triggers to win cons like Impact Tremors

Agate Instigator is already a great card on its own