The harshest criticisms were for many of the Survivors that felt out of place in the set, most of which were loudly alluding to specific 70's/80's horror films
Lilo can quest for two lore each turn, so even though shes not very strong, she can keep coming back for more
Power-boosting spells like Colossal Might or Might of Oaks can serve double-dutyyou can boost your own Ring-bearer to allow it to be blocked, or if you want to disable a potential small power blocker, you can target your opponents creature with it so your Ring-bearer can slip past
Dawnbringer Cleric is a sweet new utility creature for white, offering some good options on a relevant creature type and an even more relevant mana value
Spells and abilities that cause you to sacrifice permanents will not cause Karmic Justice's ability to trigger
That said, this card works within the context of black-border rules and seems like a sweet planeswalker design that could show up in a mainline Magic set