While none of the decks has horrible reprint value, the Cat deck is the clear winner, mostly thanks to Mirari's Wake, whichat over $13is the single most valuable reprint in any of the Commander 2017 decks
Outside those two requirements, Kaalia needs just a little bit of mana acceleration and a backup plan : Kaalia can be a bit of a monolith commander, with her deck becoming unplayable without her on the board unless you have another way to get your big bad beaters into play without hard-casting them
This is an eminently rare ability to find on a Magic card, especially with no drawbacks, save for paying a total of five mana to cast and tap it down permanently
Seasoned Dungeoneer Seasoned Dungeoneer is excellent for taking back the initiative since protection from creatures includes unblockablility
Its a relatable story for any MTG player youre playing Commander at a game store and you unknowingly drop your whole deck right into a watery ring of soda condensation left by a careless patron
As someone whos been utterly crushed by this saga on multiple occasions, let me tell you its certainly not a fun time to play against
