Peak Value: $8,000$10,000 (est.) (BGS 9+) Why It's Valuable: A legendary land from Legends that taxes all creatures, making it a staple for control decks in Legacy and Vintage
Yes, the Mirrodin version foil Chalice ($200) is quite a bit higher than either the Modern Masters 2013 or Masters 25 versions ($100), but these figures dont fully reflect just how scare foils from Mirrodin actually are these days
Since creating tokens is the typical activity of the guild, leading these tokens well is what it takes to rise in the ranks
It may give your opponent a 3/3 Elephant, but a small vanilla creature in exchange for removing the most dangerous thing on the board will leave you better off
The first damage step is for creatures with first or double strike and the second is for every other creature without those keywords
So lets take a look at which cards are the life of the party